🌐 EN ▾
November 19, 2026
Doyle's Guide

Methodology

Doyles Guide

Best Firms & Lawyers

The content within and the listing of best firms, lawyers and barristers is compiled on the back of initial online peer-review based surveys as well as extensive telephone and face to face interviews with clients, peers and relevant industry bodies.

Our research is focused on clients and legal practitioners. Publication timelines for each practice area and/or jurisdiction can be viewed here.

Most of our Personal Services Areas (Family, Crime, Estates & Succession Planning) are compiled only by way of peer based surveys and reviews.  

Jurisdictional Scope

Doyle’s Guide compiles rankings across Australia, Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom, New Zealand, Hong Kong, Singapore and other markets. The same peer-review-based methodology set out on this page is applied consistently in every jurisdiction we cover. Rankings in a newly launched market are compiled to the same standard as those in our longest-established ones: the process is driven by the assessments of local partner-level practitioners and senior counsel who work in the relevant area and market.

Where local professional structures require it, terminology is adapted to the jurisdiction — for example, the balance of solicitors and barristers, the treatment of King’s Counsel and Senior Counsel, and the naming of practice areas follow local convention. These are presentational adjustments only. The underlying basis of every ranking — independent peer review, ranked by the volume and quality of positive feedback, with tiers set by editorial discretion — does not change from one jurisdiction to the next.

Rankings Compilation

Upon conclusion of the research stage of our our ranking process, individuals and firms are ranked according to volume and quality of positive feedback.  The distinction between tiers of firms and bands of individuals is performed by way of editorial discretion.  Such editorial discretion is exercised in light of:

      1. Any clear numerical delineation that exists between firms or groups of firms;
      2. Recommendations from significant clients;
      3. Recommendations from significant peers;
      4. The firm’s/individual’s ranking in previous listing of Doyle’s Guide;
      5. Our impression of the individual during our research interview.

Rankings for the below practice areas are compiled solely on the back of peer-review (i.e. feedback from partner-level solicitors/lawyers and senior barristers who practice is dominantly focused on the area of research/rankings):

      • Criminal Law
      • Family Law
      • Estates Litigation

All research is compiled on an independent basis. 

Rankings in Doyle’s Guide cannot be purchased. No fee, advertising arrangement, subscription or commercial relationship of any kind influences whether a firm or individual is ranked, or the tier in which they appear.

The firm listing contains four categories, namely three “Tiers” and “Recommended”.

The classification of a firm into a particular tier is, more than anything else, a numbers game. Beyond numbers, particularly glowing reports from key clients and individuals can sway the balance of probabilities.

The rating of a firm in particular tier is not a definitive classification as to the skills and abilities of each individual legal practitioner within that firm.

Our listings of lawyers utilise four categories; Market Leader, Preeminent, Leading and Recommended.

Our “Market Leader” award is our most prestigious ranking.  It is awarded to an individual who, upon the conclusion of our research into a particular area and market in a given year, stands clearly ahead of their peers.  In markets and/or years where no individual ranks clearly ahead of their peers then no “Market Leader” will be awarded.

Our Preeminent and Leading lawyers are those who consistently draw the praise of both clients and peers. Our “Recommended” lawyers are those who display particular skills or attributes within the area.  All listings within each ranking category of Doyle’s Guide are displayed in alphabetical order. A position at the top of the list category in no way indicates a higher ranking or rating than a ranking at the bottom.

If you are a practitioner or firm who believes our rankings undervalue your expertise and experience, either by ranking level or non-inclusion, we encourage you to reach out to our editorial team at [email protected].

We attempt to maintain a degree of consistency across practice areas however this is not always possible and/or reflective of client needs.

In smaller jurisdictions the sample size of clients and practitioners is limited and in those situations where we are unable to obtain a sufficient body of authoritative comment to make a definitive judgment as to the classification of firms and individuals we opt to classify each of these only as “Recommended”.

Negative or disparaging comments are noted however they do not play any part in the compiling of our various rankings.

New & Smaller Markets

The sample of clients and practitioners available in a given market varies with the size of the legal community and the length of time we have researched it. Our approach to tiering reflects that:

  • Where we obtain a sufficient body of authoritative comment to distinguish reliably between practitioners, we apply our full range of categories (Market Leader, Preeminent, Leading and Recommended) as the feedback supports.
  • In a smaller market, or in the first year we research a new one, the body of feedback may support recognising a practitioner’s standing without yet supporting a fine-grained ranking between those recognised. In that situation we may list ranked practitioners within a single category, or omit the more senior tiers, rather than draw distinctions the data does not yet justify.
  • A shorter list, or a list shown within a single tier, therefore reflects a deliberate editorial decision to rank only to the level the evidence supports. It is not an incomplete listing, and it does not indicate a lower standard of research.

As a market matures and the body of feedback deepens across successive years, the tiering applied to it develops accordingly.

If you are a practitioner or firm who believes our rankings undervalue your expertise and experience, either by ranking level or non-inclusion, we encourage you to reach out to our editorial team at [email protected].

Firm Participation

Firms are not required to participate in our research or provide “submissions”. 

Firms who do wish to provide us with details as to their practice, the lawyers within it and client referees are welcome to do so however we do not invite, request or require any firm to do so.  Submission of information on particular practice groups does not affect our rankings of firms in any way.

Should you wish to provide information regarding your individual practice, practice group or firm, you are welcome to complete our formal submission process. The online forms are open to any firm, practitioner or barrister; there is no fee and no invitation is required. A submission is not required for inclusion in the rankings, and it does not of itself determine a ranking. What it does is help our editorial team understand your practice, identify the peers and clients to consult, and inform the research for the relevant ranking. Submissions are usually due two months before a ranking publishes; the deadlines are set out in the Rankings Publication Schedule. You may also send relevant information, ideally in PDF format, to [email protected].

For all practice areas other than Family Law, use the Rankings Submission form (All Practice Areas). It is for law firms, individual practitioners and barristers seeking consideration in any ranking on the schedule other than Family Law. Complete one submission per practice area and jurisdiction. The form asks for practice details, key matters from the last 12 months (each of which must be capable of being referenced publicly; confidential matters are not accepted on this form), the practitioners you wish to be considered, and at least three referees. Referees are used for verification only and are never published. An optional supporting document (PDF or Word) and an optional editorial interview can be included. The form saves as you go.

For Family Law, use the Family Law submission form. Family Law has its own form and research cycle, and the form is for family law firms, practitioners, barristers and mediators. Complete one submission per jurisdiction and select the Family Law ranking categories that apply. Given the sensitive nature of family law, matters should be described generically with the parties anonymised. All information is treated confidentially by the editorial team, and confidential matters can be marked as such and will not be published. Family Law submissions are open only for a limited period during each research cycle.

Once submitted, the material is reviewed by our editorial team and taken into account in the research for the next edition of the relevant ranking. Further guidance is on the Make a Submission page.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More